How Hydrogel Compares with Traditional Fire Suppression Agents

Fire suppression technology has changed little in decades. Water, foam, and dry powder have been the backbone of firefighting for generations, and for most conventional fire types they remain effective tools. But lithium-ion batteries are now common in transport, industry, and everyday life, and they expose the limits of these agents in specific scenarios. Understanding how hydrogel fire suppression compares with traditional fire suppression agents is a practical question for anyone responsible for fire safety where modern energy systems are present.

This comparison examines each major class of conventional extinguishing agent, explains where each falls short against lithium-ion battery fires, and sets out how Hydrogel’s mechanism addresses some of those gaps. The aim is not to dismiss proven technology. It is to give fire safety professionals and procurement teams an accurate picture of what each agent can and cannot do.

The Key Limitations of Water, Foam, and Dry Powder

Each of the three dominant traditional agents has its strengths. Each also has a distinct limitation that becomes significant in high-energy fires such as those involving lithium-ion batteries.

Water

Water is an effective coolant and remains a primary agent for many fire types, including battery fires where it can be applied in sufficient quantity. Its low viscosity, however, means it runs off hot surfaces quickly. A lithium-ion battery fire needs sustained cooling of the battery mass, not a brief temperature reduction. Water alone can struggle to maintain contact long enough to reduce the risk of reignition, and high runoff volumes create contaminated wastewater that needs managing. Electrical conductivity also limits its safe use near energised equipment unless specialist nozzle configurations are used.

Foam

Foam agents, particularly aqueous film-forming foam (AFFF), have long been effective on Class B fuel fires. However, AFFF and many other foam formulations contain PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances), a group of persistent synthetic chemicals now subject to increasingly strict regulation in Europe and elsewhere. Foam is also not designed for the deep, sustained cooling that lithium-ion battery thermal events require. It can suppress surface flames, but it is unlikely to interrupt the internal reactions that drive thermal runaway.

Dry Powder

Dry powder agents can knock down visible flames quickly. They provide little cooling, though. In a lithium-ion battery fire, residual heat inside the battery pack can stay high after the flames are out. Without active cooling, reignition is a real risk. Dry powder can also damage equipment and electronics, and the fine residue creates cleanup and respiratory hazards.

See where Hydrogel fits your fire-safety strategy
From lithium-ion batteries to existing water-based suppression systems, speak with Anogas about your application.

Discuss your application

How Hydrogel’s Mechanism Differs from Conventional Agents

Hydrogel is a water-based agent containing modified natural clay. Its advantage over plain water comes from how several mechanisms work together.

It starts as a low-viscosity fluid that can be applied through water-based suppression equipment, subject to compatibility checks. On contact with hot surfaces, its viscosity increases, so it thickens and stays in place instead of running off. This heat-responsive behaviour is intended to keep cooling focused on the heat source for longer. The gel can also expand during application, which may improve contact with hot surfaces and heat dissipation. The how Hydrogel works page explains the underlying science.

The gel layer also acts as a physical barrier. It can restrict oxygen reaching the fire and help separate escaping flammable gases from ignition sources. The modified clay particles are designed to help bind reactive lithium ions, which may contribute to stabilisation once flames are out. Hydrogel therefore combines cooling, physical isolation, gas management, and chemical stabilisation, where many conventional agents address only one or two of these.

These effects depend on the agent reaching the heat source. An externally applied agent does not necessarily reach cells inside an enclosed battery pack, so performance depends on access, battery configuration, and how the agent is delivered.

Effectiveness Against Lithium-Ion Battery Fires

Lithium-ion battery fires challenge agents that were designed for other fire types. Thermal runaway is a self-sustaining chain of reactions that can keep generating heat and flammable gases after visible flames have gone. Extinguishing the flames does not necessarily end internal heating, gas release, or the risk of reignition. This is why reignition is a recognised risk after water or dry powder is used, and why post-incident protocols typically include a monitoring period and isolation of damaged batteries. Durations vary with the incident, so follow the guidance that applies to your battery type and site.

Hydrogel is intended to address the whole fire, not only the flame phase. Its sustained cooling layer can help reduce the likelihood of reignition by combining thermal insulation, reduced oxygen availability, separation of flammable gases from ignition sources, and stabilisation of reactive lithium components. It does not guarantee that reignition will not occur, and it may not stop every reaction inside an enclosed pack.

Hydrogel also interacts with hydrogen fluoride, one of the most hazardous gases released during battery thermal runaway, and converts it into less harmful ionic components. This can reduce atmospheric hazards for operators and emergency responders. It does not eliminate them, so appropriate respiratory protection remains necessary during intervention.

Quantities depend on the application. Indicative figures range from a minimum of 2 litres for small devices such as smartphones and laptops to 300 to 10,000 litres or more for large-scale battery safety systems. Treat these as starting points and confirm the quantity needed for your battery configuration and discharge arrangement. The thermal runaway blocker application provides further detail on large-scale deployment.

Environmental and Regulatory Considerations

Regulation of fire suppression agents is changing. PFAS restrictions are tightening across the EU and in many other markets, and AFFF foam faces phase-out in multiple jurisdictions. Procurement decisions increasingly need to weigh long-term regulatory compliance alongside performance.

No PFAS is added to Hydrogel, and independent measurement found less than 1 ppb PFAS. This is an analytical result at the limit of detection, not proof of absolute absence. Hydrogel consists of more than 99% natural components, primarily modified natural clay and water, and carries a carbon footprint of less than 0.7%. Aquatic toxicity studies conducted in accordance with OECD testing guidelines confirmed non-toxicity for both algae and daphnia, supporting its classification as non-dangerous for the environment and humans under European chemical legislation. After a service life of more than 10 years, Hydrogel is expected to be recyclable as a compost-enrichment supplement rather than requiring specialist hazardous waste disposal.

For organisations working under environmental compliance frameworks, or preparing for incoming PFAS legislation, the regulatory position of a PFAS-free fire extinguisher is a legitimate procurement factor. It is separate from firefighting performance, though. Chemical composition, environmental safety, and fire performance are distinct questions, and each needs its own evidence.

See where Hydrogel fits your fire-safety strategy
From lithium-ion batteries to existing water-based suppression systems, speak with Anogas about your application.

Discuss your application

Compatibility with Existing Fire Suppression Infrastructure

A new suppression agent that needs specialist delivery systems, bespoke storage, or significant retrofit investment faces a high adoption barrier. Infrastructure change is a practical concern, so assess it early.

Hydrogel is designed to be interchangeable with water in water-based fire suppression systems. This means it can potentially be used with sprinkler networks, fixed suppression systems, and handheld extinguishers without replacing core infrastructure. Do not assume an existing system will work with Hydrogel. Verify compatibility, nozzle and discharge arrangement, agent quantity, coverage, operating temperature, and any required approvals first. Do not modify mandatory fire protection without engineering and approval checks. The ASAPs portable extinguisher range and fixed suppression systems built around Hydrogel reflect this compatibility-first design approach.

Because Hydrogel adheres to hot surfaces longer than water alone, it can help reduce the volume of contaminated runoff generated during a fire. This is a useful operational and environmental benefit compared with high-volume water application. Although Hydrogel is over 95% water by composition, it can be applied to electrical equipment up to 1,000 V when used with appropriate nozzle configurations.

No single agent suits every fire. Water, foam, dry powder, and other systems each have a role, and the right choice depends on the fire class, the equipment, and the environment. Where lithium-ion battery fire risk is growing, Hydrogel is worth evaluating as part of the wider fire-safety response, alongside the post-fire controls that any battery incident requires: residual heat management, gas hazards, monitoring, and restricted access. More technical detail is available on the Hydrogel product page.

Gerelateerde artikelen

Harry Verbakel